Join us for full benefits and know that ‘You’ll never search alone’ with your Liverpool and South West Lancashire Family History Society.

General Genealogy

Jane Dawson

By adesso |

Hello

Jane Dawson appears as the mother of William Francis Ballard in 1849 on the birth certificate. William Ballard as father. Fontenoy Street, Liverpool. Jane is my 3x great grandmother.

On the 1871 census in Liverpool her place of birth is Jersey Channel Islands.

Have never found a marriage record for her or evidence of her birth in Jersey. One contact on  Jersey told me that she may have been in a British military family there and may not appear on the records for Jersey. Also that maybe there is a Catholic register of births in Jersey???

It is rumoured that Jane and William may have been in France, Shropshire and Kent but I just don’t know about that.

Any help on Jane Dawson is most welcome!

thanks

David

 

Sorry can't find anything of use, did find a couple of baptisms around the correct time but they died at a tender age.

The only other possibility is if a mistake was made on the birth cert for her son William Francis Ballard 1849 where it states formerly Dawson… Dawson may have been a previous married name… rather than maiden… but unlikely. It’s said by a distant family member that they were in Shropshire, Kent and France. Most of the Janes registered in Jersey for around 1820 have French names. There maybe a catholic register there on Jersey… I don’t know. Interestingly, in a dna test I did the results showed an ancestral  dna link to Calais, Britanny and Aquitaine in France.

Or  maybe they weren’t ever married

tegards

David

It's possible they never married, however, it's very likely her maiden name is Dawson having had 4 children registered using the maiden name Dawson.

 

My advice would be put this to bed and revisit in a year or two when more records or resources may be available.

Fontenoy Street Liverpool 1840s/50’s

By adesso |

Hello everyone!

My great great grandfather is registered at Fontenoy St on his birth cert in 1849. William Francis  Ballard … father William Ballard, born Ireland and mother Jane Ballard formerly Dawson born Jersey Channel Islands. William Francis and subsequent generations all married in the Church of England. My question is whether Fontenoy St was an Irish Catholic neighbourhood in the 1840s/50’s? Or did Irish Catholics and Irish Protestants arriving in Liverpool live in the same neighbourhoods as each other as they were all Irish? Ballard  is an English name and not an anglicised Irish name but in Ireland  there are Catholic Ballards and Protestant as well. I wondered whether William Francis Ballard’s father was a Catholic and just allowed his family to integrate with the C of E as his wife (William Francis’s mother)was not Irish  Or whether he was a Protestant. I understand that 20% of Irish entering Liverpool were Protestants. I live in Hampshire but I have a lot of ancestry from Liverpool going back to the 1700s and beyond as well as some 2nd/3rd cousins still living there.I hope to visit soon.

Many thanks

David

PS..My 4x great grandparents are on 1841 census in Liverpool.. born Ireland. So I understand would not be escaping the famine but part of the pre existing Irish population of Liverpool.

Hi and welcome to the forum.  First I would like to ask which church they married in.  Fontenoy Street (top right square in this map) http://justme.org.uk/code/4D.html is quite into the commercial district rather than the outer area of Liverpool.  My thoughts only on this is that they chose the area to do with his business.

Very often say St Peter's church which was the Cathedral at that time, would have been chosen because of the prestige it brought rather than for any affiliation to religious creed.

If you do manage to visit, try to include a Tuesday afternoon when we host a Help Desk at the Central Library, 3rd floor by the Archives.

Thanks Mary

William Francis Ballard married in St Stephen the Martyr church. To Eliza Winifred Harding. 25 th Sept 1876… in West Derby Liverpool? He was a tinsmith. At time of marriage living in Falkland st. His father and grandfather were tinsmiths… father and grandfather born in Ireland.

regards

David

I need you to know that West Derby is a registration district that covered  much of central Liverpool and also the north area.  https://www.freebmd.org.uk/cgi/search.pl?start=1876&end=1876&sq=3&eq=3&…

Click on the "West Derby" link and then the "here" link to give you more information on the coverage, confusing to those who don't live here since there is also an area of Liverpool called West Derby and also a village of that name.

https://www.genuki.org.uk/big/eng/LAN/EdgeHill/StStephentheMartyr Here is the genuki page for St Stephen, including a map of where it was, unfortunately now long gone.  I still believe it would have been near where they lived and worked and chosen for location, I don't believe religion would have been involved, it was not particularly a Catholic area, I would have expected if they had moved here to be with friends/relatives of that religion then they may well have moved nearer the Scotland Road area, which was predominantly RC.

Hello Mary

just a thought… when the Irish were entering Liverpool in the 1840s/50s were there many RC churches or were they built later? And if there weren’t many, does that mean the Catholic Irish were marrying and baptising in C of E churches… the church closest to them?

thanks

David

I'm sure Mary or Bert will be able to add more details, but to my knowledge, St Anthony's on Scotland Road was the main RC  church serving the Vauxhall district where many of the early Irish diaspora initially settled. It was built in 1833. As the Catholic population grew, more churches were built in the area, including the Church of Our Lady of Reconciliation in Eldon Street in the southern part of Vauxhall (built in 1859-60) and St Sylvester's Church on Sylvester Street, built in 1888-89.

Never found a record of that. 
Also never found a record of Jane’s  birth in Jersey either. It said on birth cert for William Francis Ballard that she was formerly Dawson…but I don’t know if that was a previous marriage name or maiden name. The only Janes I find born in Jersey around her birth year have French surnames.

thank you

David

On my mum’s  side I also have a 3x great grandparent born in Ireland (1832.. in Cork)

She came to Kent but her name was Ellen Horn… English surname and ‘Horn’ appears in Catholic and Protestant registers in Ireland. 
Her father was listed as John Cope Horn (Mariner) This doesn’t sound very Irish. The only John Cope Horn I find was a mariner from Harwich in Essex.

My daughters great grandma on her mothers side was born in Dublin 1920… but again a very English sounding name… Edith Kettingham Palmer. I suppose it just shows that the traffic between England, Scotland and Ireland was two way in history.

regards 

David

 traffic between England, Scotland and Ireland was two way in history.

 Absolutely, just read history about the Highland Clearances and the Irish who had to come across to the mainland because the landlords gave them a push, in fact that probably covers the dates you are interested in.

I don’t know about you but I get a little annoyed when people label the Irish who fled the famine and poverty and came to Britain as ‘immigrants’.

I mean in books and in documentaries. They were Irish but also British citizens… the United Kingdom Of Great Britain and Ireland. Calling them immigrants seems to carry on with the stigma that was attached to them at that time. As I see it, my Irish ancestors were not immigrants. They were Irish but also British citizens and were coming to another part of the UK and were entitled to do so.

Regards

David

The requirement is the maiden name at registration, some did mess up but not usually more than once unless they had something to hide.

Have you got Elizabeth below?

Can you please give the names you have, 1841, Liverpool.

William and Anne’s other son William ( my 3x grt grandad) not living with the family in 1841. The word is he was in other parts of England and maybe in France/jersey… but he’s back in Liverpool by 1849 with wife Jane Dawson  and son William Francis Ballard born 1849 in Liverpool … William ( my 3rd grt grandad ) was also  a tinsmith. I believe William Francis was as well.. william Francis’s son was John Richard Ballard mm who was a french polisher, moving his family to Wrexham in 1910… dying at the Somme in the royal Welsh fusiliers and remembered in Liverpool memorial wall at the town hall?? His daughter Eleanor Ballard my dads mum.

Letitia Ballard from the above 1841 census married John Evans, 1852, Maine, USA. She died 1922, aged 88, Maine. Her parents are named, William Ballard, Tinsmith and Mother, Ann McBride.

 

There's also a burial, St Mary's Cemetery, 1847, Richard Christopher Ballard, aged 7, son of William and Jane. There's no GRO  birth registration, possibly born elsewhere other than England and Wales.

I saw that entry for Letitia on ancestry.com. It stated her parents born in England but William and Ann Ballard weee born in Ireland. I think Letitia born around 1835/6 according to 1841 Liverpool census

regards

David

However, I think a lot of the Irish entering Liverpool went on to the USA and in the ancestry.com dna test it tells me I have a genetic link to settlers from England/Ireland/Scotland to New Jersey and Pennsylvania. I think some of the Ballards went to Boston. Who knows??

But I think your one in Maine could still be a possibility… and Ann  McBride would fit in with my suspicions that they were Protestant Irish. I assume McBride is Scottish. Again… who knows!

regards and thanks for your time

David

 

Hello again

that record for an Ann McBride as Letitia Ballards mum in Maine you posted … well McBride can be an Irish or a Scottish name… so the family could have been of either faiths

regards

David

The 1905 death of Robert F Ballard, Maine,

Father, William Ballard, Tinsmith,

Mother, Ann McBride,

Both parents born, Dublin, Ireland.

You could be on the right track! I also found Robert F Ballard on ancestry.

whats interesting is the names of the children… they are Christian names passed down my Ballard line in  liverpool

regards

David

 

Dear Bert

i should say many thanks for your research  and help. 
I talked to a distant relative and I think I have pieced the story together.

william Ballard(4x grt grandad) died in 1845 after a days fever. Ann his wife( nee McBride ) took family soon after to America where she is buried along with her children. 
william Ballard  ( my 3x grt grandad) was either elsewhere in England/Jersey or didn’t follow family to America. He had  William Francis ballard in Liverpool in 1849. William f had John Richard ballard in 1882 in Liverpool. John Richard has Eleanor ballard my grandma in Liverpool in 1906.

thanks again

David

Do you have any clues as to whereabouts in Ireland they came from?  and have you come across this website, one of the best for Irish research, especially since, if you find the entry you need, it often includes an original image from either Parish Registers or Birth/Marriage Registers, although they would be a little late for your family.  https://www.irishgenealogy.ie/en/

That confirms it Bert. All things in place and it all adds up. I see Robert F Ballard married in Massachusetts and I do remember a distant relative (Dave Maguire) telling me some of the Ballards went to Boston. They probably moved to Maine, close by.

regards

David

What is interesting is that I read Dublin at one time had a Protestant population constituting 20%…. Many skilled workers like smiths etc coming from England and settling. I now believe the Ballard family were Catholics…it’s good as I already have some Scottish relatives on my tree who lived in Liverpool. George Murray and Mary Newton… traced her to Edinburgh and him to Eccles in Berwickshire. In Berwickshire the family is mixed with English families as is border country.

regards

David

Joshua Tunstall was the Minister for William Ballard, 1845.

 

click to return to<br />
Liverpool Home & Contents

Claremont Grove Independent Chapel, Kirkdale
in the County of
-- Lancashire --

click to return to Lancashire Home

At the time of the establishment of this Congregational Chapel in 1829, Kirkdale was a village lyng some two miles beyond the outer reaches of Liverpool with a rapidly expanding population of between 2 and 3,000 persons.

The building, situated in Claremont Grove, was constructed to meet the devotional needs of local non-conformists and was opened on Wednesday, October 28th 1829 being described thus; “a neat and commodious chapel, calculated to accommodate from 3 to 400 persons, and capable of admitting a gallery." Preachers at the opening where the Reverends John Kelly and Dr. Raffles1.

The Rev. Joshua Tunstall became Minister in 1830 at a time when congregations averaged “60 to 80 in the morning, and from 100 to 200 in the evening". Tunstall remained as Pastor for 30 years resigning in 1858. A succession of Ministers followed, with an American, the Rev. F. Wallace becoming Pastor in 1866. Wallace led the move from Claremont Grove to the present building in Westminster Road (now the United Reformed Church) in 18721.

The original chapel in Claremont Grove (now Fountains Road) was purchased by the Roman Catholic diocese in 1870 and opened as the Church of St. John the Evangelist. A new church replaced the original chapel building in 18852.

It appears Joshua Tunstall around that time buried everyone, not everyone could be of the same religion, same minister covered all.

I would say that the maiden name of William’s wife Ann  ‘McBride’ probably makes them Catholic looking at the denomination maps of Ireland for 1901.

Whether they be Catholic or Protestant I will have a Guinness tonight in their name!

Next to get beyond the brick wall on my mum’s side.. not a Liverpool matter but Irish again.

Ellen Horn born Cork 1831/2. Married a Thomas Brown in 1855 at St Nicholas Church Deptford Green.

Lived  in Eltham Kent.

Names her father as John Cope Horn (a mariner) on marriage cert.

The only John Cope Horn I find is a mariner from Harwich in Essex. 
 

Ellen Horn is my 3x great grandmother.

Any tips would be most appreciated as I have been looking for 3 years and can get no further.
 

regards

David

 

The most obvious way to go is look for a marriage with a male Horn and female Cope

Name: John Cope
Gender: Male
Birth Date: 17 Aug
Baptism Date: 9 Sep 1789
Baptism Place: Harwich, St Nicholas, Essex, England
Father: Stephen Horn
Mother: Susannah Horn

 

Name: Stephen Horne
Gender: Male
Marriage Date: 31 Jan 1773
Marriage Place: Dovercourt, All Saints, Essex, England
Spouse: Susannah Cope

 

Name: Ellen Horn
Baptism Age: 7
Birth Date: 2 Dec 1816
Baptism Date: 19 Apr 1824
Baptism Place: Harwich, St Nicholas, Essex, England
Search Photos: Search for 'Harwich, St Nicholas' in the UK City, Town and Village Photos collection
Phillimore Ecclesiastical Parish Map:

View this parish

Father: John Cope Horn
Mother: Elizabeth Horn

If this is the Ellen Brown and family, it can not be the above daughter of John Cope Horn.

Name: Ellen Brown
Gender: Female
Age: 30
Relation: Wife
Estimated Birth Year: 1831
Where born: Cork, Ireland
Civil parish: Eltham
County/Island: Kent
Country: England
Registration district: Lewisham
Sub-registration district: Eltham
ED, institution, or vessel: 1
Neighbors:
Household schedule number: 116
Household Members (Name) Age Relationship
Thomas Brown 30 Head
Ellen Brown 30 Wife
Thomas Brown 4 Son
Timothy Brown 2 Son
Martha Brown 7/12 Daughter
Henry Wallace 27 Boarder
Thomas Davis 30 Boarder

Location of Old Pub

By Horsley2016 |

Hello there,
I've an Ancestor, James Brown crop up in the 1871 Census as a Barman. His Mother Anastasia Hall is there too as a 'visitor!' The address is 355 Park Rd, Toxteth. Joseph Smith is the 'Licensed Victualler' born in Brazil (I think!) It looks like next door is a Greengrocer (357- 359)- name possible George Pickles. Would love to know what the pub was called, any thoughts of where to search are most welcome!
Mx

I've not yet come across a name for the premises?

Below is a snippet from the Liverpool Daily Post, August 12, 1868, Title, Public Houses in Liverpool, applications for victuallers license.

I suspect, bh. is for Beer house, as far as I know not all beer houses had an official title or was a named premises?

The Electoral Rolls for 355 Park Rd record the property as house, 1870+/- 5 years, some properties with duel purpose are recorded as so, for example, house and shop, etc. Public Houses are also recorded elsewhere and the occupant of 45 Dove Street was recorded as a Beer House Keeper. The 1881 Liverpool Directory, 355 has the owner as a Fruiterer. Sight of a 1871 Directory would help, Liverpool Library?

I was going to say that very often a licenced victualler may have simply sold beer etc. from his front room, even selling through his window.  But it may be that Bertie has solved this one.

Oh my goodness. I am SO very sorry for ignoring everyone!!! I absolutely hadn't seen these replies for some reason, though I've been logged in!! Everyone must think I'm really rude! I wonder if because I had trouble posting it (Mary I did notice you said it hadn't shown up originally) if there's been some glitch in the system?

Your information is so useful and kind. I have been sifting through it. Since my post I am now wobbly about my security over the Anastasia line and so am working to prove / disprove this. It's amazing how many Anastasia's could actually exist! However, Bertieones found certificate (which I didn't have!) has confirmed a Margaret Jane Hall, which I know exists... It's one of those mysteries I think I'll dip in and out of for now until I have more clear time. I have been taken over by sifting through McCarthy relatives and that's giving me headaches!

Again - to all of you who replied, I am so sorry! However, huge thanks for all the time and extremely useful and vital information. It is so much appreciated.
Best wishes
Mx

Ships in the Mersey harbour - identifying

By expat2021 |

Hi everybody, Does anyone know what kind of shops are in the picture. The long and flat ones sitting deep in the water. Or what they were used for?
Happy New Year and many thanks,
Pat

Was he Denison or Johnson? Re-visited, more discoveries, more problems.

By Martin-46 |

Some members may recall the lengthy series of posts early in 2021 where I asked for help to find out more about my grandfather John Fleming Denison Johnson, born in Liverpool in 1891 but who ‘disappeared’ in the mid-1920s. He died in Liverpool in 1973. With the help of several forum contributors, we made some remarkable discoveries along the way but failed in answering one important question: who was my grandfather’s father?

Since then, I have made further discoveries but, once again, I am seeking help to delve deeper.

To recap: my grandfather’s mother was born Sarah Ann Dennison in Leeds in 1856. (For some unknown reason she later changed her name to Lilly or Lillian Johnson – which is a good enough reason to explain why my grandfather later added Johnson as his surname.) His birth certificate records his given names as John Fleming but shows no entry for his father’s name – suggesting that he was illegitimate.

In 1891, the year my grandfather was born, census records show Sarah Ann Denison living with her sister at 373 Prescott Road. Next door, at 375, lived a John Fleming. This gave rise to the hypothesis that John Fleming had illegitimately fathered my grandfather with ‘the girl next door’ and that was why his mother had given him the Christian names John Fleming.

The only way to verify this hypothesis seemed to be by DNA matching. John Fleming was one of 8 siblings born to Irish immigrant parents. The search for living descendants of any one of these proved fruitless; there seemed to be none. An elder brother had married but seemed to have had no children and a younger sister had married, had children and two grandchildren both of whom died in infancy. There the Fleming dynasty seemed to have come to an end.

However, a short time ago, by one of those strokes of luck that every genealogist dreams of, I discovered that John Fleming’s sister Margaret (b. 1859, Dublin) had married a Denis C Kenny in 1881 (also Irish). Within a few years they had emigrated to New York and had 4 children. One of these, John Leo Kenny (b. 1886, New York) had married a Grace Elizabeth Davis (b. 1900, Quebec). Between them, this couple had 11 children only one of whom, Lillian Edna Kenny, b. 1928) appears to have married; this was to a Gordon Edwin Beall (b. 1919).  Her obituary is at :

https://www.newspapers.com/clip/115469694/lillian-edna-beall-obituary-2…

The obituary records her having one daughter, Alice (living in Oakville, Ontario), and four grandsons, David, Scott, Timothy, and Ryan (presumably all with same father).

The Canada, Obituary Collection, 1898-Current lists the obituary of an Alice Corbett :

https://www.ancestry.co.uk/discoveryui-content/view/234783240:8961?ssrc…

This records her mother as Lillian Edna Beall. It would thus appear that Alice Beall married someone by the name of Corbett. Unfortunately, the obituary itself is not reproduced nor is the date of her death.

Remarkably, I came across the Kenny Family Tree on Ancestry; owner: Alice Beall. She had subscribed to Ancestry in September 2015 but unfortunately her tree comprised of only 4 entries – one of which was her mother. This suggests that she either got fed up or died before adding further to the tree.

This where my luck has run out. I can find no further information about Alice (Beall) Corbett or about any of her 4 sons.

If I have any hope of carrying out a DNA investigation, I clearly need to find out more – best of all contact one of the sons.

Help ! !
 

Some members may recall the lengthy series of posts early in 2021 where I asked for help to find out more about my grandfather John Fleming Denison Johnson, born in Liverpool in 1891 but who ‘disappeared’ in the mid-1920s. He died in Liverpool in 1973. With the help of several forum contributors, we made some remarkable discoveries along the way but failed in answering one important question: who was my grandfather’s father?

 

Since then, I have made further discoveries but, once again, I am seeking help to delve deeper.

 

To recap: my grandfather’s mother was born Sarah Ann Dennison in Leeds in 1856. (For some unknown reason she later changed her name to Lilly or Lillian Johnson – which is a good enough reason to explain why my grandfather later added Johnson as his surname.) His birth certificate records his given names as John Fleming but shows no entry for his father’s name – suggesting that he was illegitimate.

 

In 1891, the year my grandfather was born, census records show Sarah Ann Denison living with her sister at 373 Prescott Road. Next door, at 375, lived a John Fleming. This gave rise to the hypothesis that John Fleming had illegitimately fathered my grandfather with ‘the girl next door’ and that was why his mother had given him the Christian names John Fleming.

 

The only way to verify this hypothesis seemed to be by DNA matching. John Fleming was one of 8 siblings born to Irish immigrant parents. The search for living descendants of any one of these proved fruitless; there seemed to be none. An elder brother had married but seemed to have had no children and a younger sister had married, had children and two grandchildren both of whom died in infancy. There the Fleming dynasty seemed to have come to an end.

 

However, a short time ago, by one of those strokes of luck that every genealogist dreams of, I discovered that John Fleming’s sister Margaret (b. 1859, Dublin) had married a Denis C Kenny in 1881 (also Irish). Within a few years they had emigrated to New York and had 4 children. One of these, John Leo Kenny (b. 1886, New York) had married a Grace Elizabeth Davis (b. 1900, Quebec). Between them, this couple had 11 children only one of whom, Lillian Edna Kenny, b. 1928) appears to have married; this was to a Gordon Edwin Beall (b. 1919).  Her obituary is at :

 

https://www.newspapers.com/clip/115469694/lillian-edna-beall-obituary-2013/?xid=637

 

The obituary records her having one daughter, Alice (living in Oakville, Ontario), and four grandsons, David, Scott, Timothy, and Ryan (presumably all with same father).

 

The Canada, Obituary Collection, 1898-Current lists the obituary of an Alice Corbett :

 

https://www.ancestry.co.uk/discoveryui-content/view/234783240:8961?ssrc=pt&tid=174552334&pid=162440125367

 

This records her mother as Lillian Edna Beall. It would thus appear that Alice Beall married someone by the name of Corbett. Unfortunately, the obituary itself is not reproduced nor is the date of her death.

 

Remarkably, I came across the Kenny Family Tree on Ancestry; owner: Alice Beall. She had subscribed to Ancestry in September 2015 but unfortunately her tree comprised of only 4 entries – one of which was her mother. This suggests that she either got fed up or died before adding further to the tree.

 

This where my luck has run out. I can find no further information about Alice (Beall) Corbett or about any of her 4 sons.

 

If I have any hope of carrying out a DNA investigation, I clearly need to find out more – best of all contact one of the sons.

 

Help ! !

Martin,

Unfortunately I can't seem to progress by traditional methods of research, Ancestry, etc. No doubt you have exhausted those methods yourself.

I took a look at close friend, Aileen Emard. It appears Aileen has mention as a special friend among a number of obituaries and in family members obits. Special friend struck me as a visitor from a charitable or church organisation. A lady of the same name is/was connected to the Gateway Church, 128 Mary St, Arnprior. Her last mention I could find was her brother in laws orbit, January 2022. I think it's worth a punt and try to make contact with Aileen and see if she has knowledge of the Corbett's sons. The church has an Email address and also a Facebook page which I can't help with (not on Facebook)  

 

 

Many thanks Bert for your efforts. It is a good idea to try to contact Aileen Emard. Also I will try the nursing home where Lillian Beal died and the Salvation army which is also mentioned in the obituary. I find it strange that I can't find an obituary for daughter Alice. I have used Newspapers.com but to no avail. I think that part of the problem might be because Ancestry are not very advanced in digitising records from Canada. Interestingly I contacted someone called Liam Corbett from Dublin who showed up as a partial DNA match to me - I did so because it is the first time I ever had a DNA match from anyone in Ireland. He replied saying that he was trying to trace his brother who was adopted at birth (as was he). It was only yesterday that I realised that I was dealing with another Corbett as well as searching for them in Canada. Surely it can only be a coincidence that the same surname has cropped up. I have contacted him again but not yet had a reply. I will let you know if anything turns up from these very tenuous leads. Thanks again. Martin.

Thanks Bert, yes I already have that link but it leaves me a bit puzzled: how has Ancestry linked the two names Beall and Corbett. Lillian Beall's obituary simply mentions 'daughter Alice' with no mention of her married surname. Yet when you put in a search for Alice Beall, Ancestry returns with Alice Corbett; so somehow it knows that they are one and the same person. How? Somewhere I think there is an obituary for Alice Corbett but I have searched using Newspapers.com and can find nothing. So maybe she isn't dead. Meanwhile I have messaged the church in Arnprior. I'll keep you posted. Martin.

I had hoped that the Electoral Records might have helped with the Emards but unfortunately there is no mention, sorry.

Thanks for your help Mary. This is proving to be a tough one to crack. Surprising because there are so many names to go at. I have messaged the church that Bert identified and also the nursing home where Lillian Beall died. I will also try the undertakers. Thanks again, Martin.

Once again Bert’s magical skills have turned up trumps.  Alice Corbett (Beall) is still living. Taking up Bert’s suggestion, I emailed the Gateway Church in Arnprior and received a positive response; they provided the email address of Aileen Emard and, also forwarded to her my request for information. Her reply came a few days later : "I am a friend of Alice Corbett for many years & she has MS & lives in a nursing home in Oakville, so have forwarded this to her".

There are several nursing homes listed in Oakville so even if Alice is not well enough or not disposed to reply, I may be lucky to make contact with one or more of her four sons through contact with a home.

It’s still a long road to try to obtain DNA results but things are looking positive. Thanks everyone for help. Martin.

Dorothy Nina Forshaw nee Stenton

By Phil F |

Dorothy Nina Stenton, 26, Spinster, of 42 Devon Street, married my Great Uncle William Charles Forshaw, 26, Bachelor of 25 Seymour Street, on 6 April 1915 in The Register Office, Liverpool. Her father was recorded as John Stenton (deceased), Corporation Foreman. I have the marriage certificate.

The 1911 Census shows Dorothy Stenton at 79 Kempston Street (a lodging house), Liverpool, age 21, single, waitress at at hotel, born in Sheffield.

A 1910 record from the Liverpool Board Of Guardians Workhouse, Admissions & Discharges (Religious Creed Register) shows Dorothy Mina (sic) Stenton there from 22 March 1910 to 4 April 1910 Age: 21 Address: 79 Kempston St. Religion: CE.

I have not been able to find any earlier records for Dorothy.

Dorothy's husband, William Charles Forshaw was working as a tailor's cutter in the 1911 Census (Charles Wm. Forshaw, 22, at 37 Seymour Street, Liverpool). He was a tailor on the 1915 marriage certificate. He was convicted of receiving stolen goods in 1914 and, perhaps because of this, embarked on a career at sea, where he was killed due to enemy action in 1940. The Liverpool Echo obituary, published 10 July 1940 on page 8, stated Charles Forshaw was a member of the Derby Masonic Lodge No. 724, an overseas member of the Liverpool Press Club and had worked for Alfred Holt for 25 years. His parents were mentioned, but nothing about a wife.

The 1921 Census shows Dorothy Forshaw Head, 31y 4m Married, born Sheffield, Shop Assistant living at 39 Leopold Road, Liverpool. No other people were recorded at the address.

The 1923 Electoral Register shows Dorothy Forshaw at 2 Bannerman Street, Liverpool.
The 1924, 1925, 1926, 1927-28 and 1928-29 Electoral Registers show Dorothy and Charles Forshaw at 2 Bannerman Street.
The 1930-31 Electoral Register for 2 Bannerman Street shows just two people, John and Ivy Crooks here.

The 1930-31 Electoral Register shows William Charles Forshaw at 25 Seymour Street with mother, Sarah Jane Forshaw and other family members. Dorothy is not shown here.

So, the last record I have for Dorothy Nina Forshaw is the 1928-29 Electoral Register. I am curious to know what happened to her.
Can anyone find records for her before 1910 or after 1929?

Phil

 

 

 

Just to follow on from Mary A's comment in the other thread, I too have had a look at your problem and I can't find a new angle to attack it from.  Do you have any more details on Dorothy's admission to the workhouse? I'm assuming, perhaps wrongly, that this was a medical admission. If so, is there an indication of which ward she was assigned to?

Hi Andy, Thanks for having a look at this 'brick wall'. I can see no indication as to why Dorothy was in the workhouse. The image of the record is available on Familysearch - https://www.familysearch.org/ark:/61903/3:1:939N-QX97-3Z?cc=4489063&nbsp; or look at Film # 004633750  Image 297 of 796 - it's the bottom line on the sheet.
The 'Location of Pauper' is recorded as '8' and the Ward discharged from also '8'.

 

 

 

 

 

Alice Gore

By Andy J |

As the forums have been a little quiet for a while, and to stop Bertie getting bored, I thought I’d drop in a naughty little problem I’ve been wrestling with recently. It’s rather like someone got three separate jigsaws each featuring a different picture of an old cottage, and threw all the pieces in the same box with no picture on the lid, and the dog then chewed some of the pieces. Lots of bits fit together mechanically speaking but the pictures don’t match. With others, the pictures appear to match but the pieces don’t fit very well. Oh, and did I mention, I think quite a lot of bits got sucked up by the vacuum cleaner.

The question is: who were Alice Gore’s parents?

These are the facts I am reasonably sure about: Alice Gore married John Jackson in St Mary’s, Edge Hill on 14 April 1884. She was 18 and a spinster. She said her father’s name was Thomas and his occupation was labourer. The parish register doesn’t say if he was deceased or not. Both bride and groom signed the register and the witnesses do not appear to be family members. Alice’s address at the time of the marriage was Lilly Grove, Cherry Lane (the image of the marriage register entry is on Ancestry if anyone needs to look at it). All subsequent census /1939R entries for her are fairly consistent about her year and place of birth, namely 1866 and Liverpool or Walton. The 1921 census puts her age one year out (ie she is shown as a year older than in all the other entries) but the month accords with her date of birth in the 1939R which is 28 Feb 1866. She died in the first quarter in 1947 (Liverpool North 10d 235) aged 81 which suggests that she died in March just after her birthday. I don’t yet have her or John’s death certificates, but I believe she died before John, his death probably being in 1949 (Q4 1949 Liverpool North 10d 141 age 87).

The first problem is that there is no birth in the Liverpool region which was registered in either of the first two quarters of 1866 in the name Alice Gore, or any reasonable variations of both names. The nearest is in Q4 1866 (West Derby 8b 469) with the mother’s maiden name McComb. The only Gore/McComb marriage which fits is that of Joseph Gore and Ellen McComb at St Peter’s on 27 Aug 1866. Joseph and Ellen can be found living with Joseph’s mother and father in Greenfield Lane, Litherland in 1871 along with daughters Alice 5, Margaret 3 and Ellen 1, all born Litherland. So definitely a possible for the parents, if we accept Litherland=Liverpool and Alice getting her father’s name wrong. That might be excusable since Joseph died in 1877 when our Alice would have been 11. However the mother Ellen doesn’t remarry and there appears to be no Thomas who might have been a stepfather-like figure. But Joseph did have an older brother named Thomas (who was married to Eleanor Balshaw) also living in Greenfield Lane, Litherland in 1871. Thomas and Eleanor had two sons at that time. There are also no relevant baptisms over the period.

There are six other Thomas Gores around the Liverpool area who the right age to be candidates for Alice Gore’s father, but unfortunately none of them appear to have a daughter named Alice at the time of the 1871 census.

It’s now time to examine a couple of pieces that the dog has chewed. That means turning to that most reliable source of inspiration when all else fails: other people’s Ancestry trees. There’s one entitled Rimmer Family Tree which does look promising. It has a 5 year old Alice’s parents as Peter and Martha Gore living at 9 Lilly Grove in 1871, along with son Thomas 12 and daughter Margaret 8, with Alice and Maragret born in Walton. So we have a Lilly Grove link, the correct age and place of birth; it’s just the father’s name which is the problem. Except that when we look more closely at Peter and Martha there’s a rather bigger problem. They are not man and wife, but brother and sister. Their parents are James and Martha Gore who can be found living at Back Lane (Eaton Road today), West Derby from 1841 to 1861. In the 1881 and 1891 censuses Peter and Martha are still at 9 Lilly Grove but are now shown as brother and sister. In 1881 Alice is no longer at home but her sister Margaret aged 17 and single is at 9 Lilly Grove and shown as Peter Gore’s neice. There’s no sign of Peter Gore ever marrying although it is obviously possible that the Thomas, Alice and Margaret shown in the 1871 census were his children, but equally they might have been Martha’s. So if Margaret in 1881 really was Peter’s neice, who was her father – one of Peter’s siblings perhaps? He had 3 brothers and a sister. William born 1823 and John born in 1824 were older than Peter. Next came Martha who was two years younger than Peter and is the one who lived with him at Lilly Grove until he died in 1896 and she then died in 1898. Peter’s youngest brother was James born 1833. All three of Peter’s brothers married in the period 1850 - 1856. Both John and James can be accounted for until at least 1871 and neither had a child named Alice or Margaret. Unfortunately the oldest, William, goes missing, along with the rest of his family, after the birth of his daughter Elizabeth in 1853. There are no other Gore children registered with his wife’s maiden name of Padley (or the variant Pedley) after Elizabeth.

There is one other dog-chewed piece which may or may not be significant. In the 1891 census for 9 Lilly Grove (that is, some seven years after our Alice married John Jackson) the household consists of Peter Gore head, unmarried, 63, dock labourer (in previous years he was an agricultural labourer); Martha Gore, sister, widow, aged 61 whose occupation was laundress; Mary Moorecroft, daughter, widow, 36 also a laundress; and Richard Moorecroft, nephew aged 5. Beside the entry for Mary’s relationaship to the head of the household is the word sister which has been crossed out, apparently by the enumerator. Assuming that Richard is Mary’s child, his relationship to the head of the household should be grandson, rather than nephew. This Mary is almost certainly the same Mary who appeared in the household of Peter’s father Joseph Gore at Back Lane in 1861 where the relationship was granddaughter, born 1854. She went on to marry Edward Moorcroft at Holy Trinity, Walton Beck on 6 April 1878. At the time of the marriage Mary’s address was Lilly Grove. In the Banns on the previous 3 Sundays both bride and groom were recorded as of this parish. Edward died in early 1886 aged 36 and was buried at Walton on the Hill. The recording of Martha as a widow is a complete mystery. In all the previous censuses she was shown as unmarried except for the anomaly in 1871 where she was recorded as Peter’s wife. And if she married after the 1881 census she would have been aged between 50 and 60 and seemingly not in need of someone to support her into retirement since she was living with her brother. Needless to say there’s no obvious marriage for her.

For the sake of completeness, in the two years 1865 -1866 there were ten births registered in England with the name Alice Gore. Five of these were in London or Kent and so, even though one of them features a father named Thomas, I have discounted them for now. Of the remaining five, one was the Gore/McComb birth in the West Derby registration district at the end of 1866, and the other four were registered in Wigan. I have done some prelimimary work on these Wigan families and only one features a father named Thomas Gore. He was a widower in 1871, aged 36 and a pit labourer living in Ince-in-Makerfield with his daughters Alice aged 6 and Elizabeth aged 4. Both daughters were born in Ince, and their father in Orell. By 1881 there’s no sign of Thomas, and the two daughters are living in the household of their uncle Richard Gore and working as servants. Since the uncle was a shopkeeper, the nieces may have been helping out in the shop. But apart from that one family, I have no reason to look at the Wigan Gores in more detail at this stage.

I don’t think the whereabouts of our Alice at the time of the 1881 census is going to be much help in finding her parents. For what it’s worth there aren’t exactly many possibilities to choose between. The Rimmer Family Tree suggests that she’s at 49 Rimrose Road, Bootle cum Linacre in the Smith household, aged 14 and working as a domestic servant, born in Litherland. The age and place of birth suggests this is more likely to be the Alice who was the daughter of Thomas and Ellen (nee McComb) who was born at end of 1866. However the only other Alice Gores of the right age are mainly down in London or Kent and have families and places of birth down there also, so I am discounting them for now.

Sadly, there are no wills for any of the key players.

Can anyone solve this jigsaw or suggest a way of attacking the problem which I haven’t thought of?

It appears Margaret married James Henry Pretten, image below, Alice Gore, Witness.

Margaret also declares her father as Thomas, Labourer. If Martha was Peter's sister and it looks like that is correct as I can't see her declaring so on 2 censuses' if it wasn't and also Margaret as niece to the head of household if that wasn't correct. It may suggest Martha never married and raised the children in her name or changed their name after a fallout with Thomas?

It doesn't appear a Gore married a Gore, could be their fathers name was Thomas ??? and they have used their own maiden surname and his first name to save embarrassment.

I suspect Mary Gore/Moorecroft was the daughter of Martha Gore Jnr, 1861 census. She declares an Unknown father; I'm wondering did the other 2 girls make up a name as a cover up?

Sorry, saw this after I posted my other reply. Yes, more confirmation of the theory, which is looking pretty watertight. Thanks as ever, Bertie. As a matter of interest what year and church was that baptism?

Hi Bertie,

Thanks so much for those extra details. I deliberately didn't add my theory when posing the (very long) question, but you have cconfirmed it. I think the Lilly Grove link is too significant to ignore, leading to the strong probability that either Peter or Martha (but not both) was a parent to the children.  I also thought that Martha was the more likely of the two. It would seem that the mysterious Thomas, whoever he might have been, hung around long enough to father at least two, if not all four, of the children, unless of course his name was made up as you mention. It will be interesting, once I get Martha's death certificate to see who registered the death: was her brother Peter or one of the children? Clearly the deceased herself may have been something of a stranger to the register office!

The name of Thomas for the firstborn son (b. 1859/60) takes on an extra significance in the circumstances. There was a Thomas Gore whose birth was registered in Q1 1860 in West Derby, but the mother's maiden name of Higham threw me off the scent, despite the fact that there was no sign of a Gore/Higham marriage in the ten years leading up to his birth. There is also a baptism for a Thomas Gore on 13 April 1860 with parents James and Martha Gore, but once again I was thrown off track by the James Gore reference. Margaret Gore's birth may have been the one registered in Q4 1862 in West Derby where the mother's maiden name was given as 'Hughes'. If so, that would mean she was 20 by the time of her marriage, so a minor as shown in the marriage entry. I think I might invest in these birth certificates just to see what address and mother's details appear on them. I also need to spend some time on Ancestry looking for Thomas's (b. 1859/60) marriage to see if anything appears where his father's name should be.

Once again, many thanks, Bertie, for clinching this problem.

 

 

Name: Mary Gore
Birth Date: 6 Oct
Baptism Date: 15 Nov 1854
Baptism Place: West Derby, St Mary, Lancashire, England
Parish as it Appears: West Derby

I'm not sure how I could have missed this: in the 1851 census Martha and Peter are living with their parents James and Martha at Back Lane, West Derby. The daughter Martha was aged 21 and we now know, thanks to Bertie, that she went on to have her daughter Mary on 6 Oct 1854. And chances are, the father's name might be Thomas. Also staying in the same household in 1851 is the 24 year unmarried lodger Thomas Case. 

Hard to be sure what happened to him after that but there is an unmarried Thomas Case aged 32 and a carter, boarding at 38 Westmorland Street Liverpool in 1861. There is another Thomas Case aged 35 in 1861, but he had married on 18 Sep 1853 and had 4 children with wife Sarah by 1861, so he is probably not the same person as the single lodger Thomas from 1851. 

 

I had a go at Thomas Case yesterday but couldn't find anything conclusive, with lack of registration and I did look if any of the children were registered Case and perhaps changed their name later, however, not so. James, 1851 census is a Gardener, perhaps Thomas Case worked with him and declares himself a Gardener at his marriage to Sarah Johnson, all supposition though.

Thanks, Bertie. I'm going to leave him as a 'maybe' for now. Alice was the wife of one my ggrandfather's brothers so it's not really important that I completely pin down her ancestry. But thanks for all your help.

 

Added: There was the death of a Thomas Case Q3 1865 West Derby 8b 447, but with no age given. So late enough that he could have been Alice's father and his death a pretty good reason for not marrying Martha, if that was ever contemplated.

Thanks for the link Bertie.  I have used the GRO quite a few times in the past to search for more details, for example,  mother's maiden names, but I just didn't think about using it to look up the Thomas Case death.

I now have Martha Gore's death cert. I wasn't expecting what it says under her rank or profession. Looks like the children were mightly confused. Mary the eldest daughter, who is the one who reported the death, put unknown for her father when she married Edward Moorcroft.

Marion Fisher

By Peter Jolliffe |

Marion/Marian Douglas was born Q3 1939 to parents Joseph James Douglas and Louisa Fisher. In 1964 she married Kenneth Turner at St. George Church, Huyton.

I can't find any more info about her after 1964. Any help will be most appreciated.

Peter

Peter,

It's not a good time period for research with few records available. In the event they are still alive, the forum doesn't encourage living people being discussed. However, a same named couple appear in the Liverpool Electoral Rolls, 1965/66/67 which you should be able to find.

Who was Robert Barton?

By Gwebb1 |

Hi everyone.

This is a bit of a longshot but I was wondering if anyone could help me find Robert Barton on any official records.  The only time I can find him mentioned is on his daughter's marriage certificate in 1872 - Isabella Barton married Thomas Maddox in Liverpool in Dec 1872.  Robert is described as a 'ship carpenter' and there is nothing to indicate whether he was dead or alive at the time of the wedding.  Other records suggest Isabella was born in Liverpool in the early 1850s.

Quite a while ago now I asked for help in finding Isabella's birth records but unfortunately nothing turned up.  Now I am trying a different tack and seeing if I can find Robert in apprentice records or on a ship (I thought this might explain why I cannot find him on any census records) but I am not very familiar with using these records.

Any help and/or ideas would be much appreciated.

Glen

 

Lynne,

Something to ponder, the marriage of Thomas Maddox/Isabella Barton, a witness named Sarah Mills or Hills?

 

The previous census below,

1871 England Census - Ancestry.co.uk

1871, Transcription errors.

Ellice Davis 62 Head
Margaret Davis 57 Wife
Maria Davis 23 Daughter
James Davis 19 Son
Frederick Davis 15 Son
Isabella Borton 19 Servant, Birkenhead.
Sarah Mills 27 Servant

 

The parents of this Isabella Barton appear to be Thomas Barton/Esther Roscoe, Thomas recorded on the 1851 census as a Mariner.

 

I'll keep looking, Thomas Barton seems to be AWOL from further census, etc. With the absence of a Robert Barton and a Ships Carpenter could be described as a Mariner. I'm wondering if some sort of mistake has been made, purposely or otherwise.   

Could be a good shout, Bert.  I had seen the census record before but never made the link with Sarah Hill on Isabella's marriage certificate.  And, of course, Isabella married some 18 months after the census so could well have kept in touch with Sarah.

Another fact that could support your theory is that in 1886 Isabella had a daughter whom she called Esther.  The child died in 1887.

Do I hear a brick wall falling down?!  Just the little matter of the father's first name ......

Glen

Bert:  I don't seem able to find the records you refer to (i.e. Thomas Barton on the 1851 census and a birth record that shows he and Esther had a daughter called Isabella).  

Can you point me in the right direction, pleas?

Thanks, 

Glen

There is a Thomas Barton death registered 1852, Wirral, about the correct age, if the correct Thomas and died early in Isabella's life perhaps added to the confusion. Especially if Esther got together with someone called Robert without remarrying and Isabella considered this Robert her father and what we have come across before, use this man's name along with her own maiden name at her marriage, something to consider.

BARTON, ISABELLA     ROSCOE  

GRO Reference: 1851  J Quarter in WIRRAL  Volume 19  Page 400

Thomas Barton married Esther Roscoe, 10 March 1851, St Mary's, Birkenhead 

Thanks, Bert - got them.   This evening, I will send for the 1851 Wirral birth certifcate for Isabella (seems like I may have been too premature when I dismissed it some 15 years ago!) and the 1852 death certifcate for Thomas to see if I can glean anything new.  I'll post my findings when they come.

If anyone has the time, I wonder if someone could take a look at the 1871 census referred to by Bert and tell me where you think Sarah Mills was born.  The Ancestry transcription says Dorchester but as far as I am aware there is no such place in Yorks.  I won't prejudice anyone by saying what I think (hope!) the place might be.

The look-up ref for the 1871 census is: Sarah Mills, d.o.b. 1844, place of birth:  Yorkshire.

Looking forward to your responses.

Glen

Family Search

Sarah Mills

Enumeration District 34
Event Type Census, 1871.
Birth Year (Estimated) 1844
Birthplace Doncaster, Yorkshire
Marital Status Married
Occupation Cook
Relationship to Head of Household Servant
Entry Number 15

I was hoping the birthplace would be transcribed as Doncaster as I had found a Sarah Hill born there in 1844 (although a Sarah Mills was also born there in 1846!) so I was beginning to be hopeful I could show that the Sarah Mills on the 1871 census was the same person as the Sarah Hill on Isabella's marriage certifcate in 1872, thereby making the link between my great grandmother and the child born in Birkenhead.

However, given that it now turns out that Sarah Mills was in fact a married name (I think I must have read what I expected to see in that column and the writing is most unclear), I'm struggling to prove anything at all.

I've also looked without success to see if Esther Barton remarried - perhaps someone called Robert! - so it looks as though my brick wall is going to stand for a while longer yet.

Do let me know if you spot anything else, Bert.

Regards,

Glen

I followed up Bert's idea and sent for the birth certificate for the Isabella Barton born in Birkenhead in 1851.  I was hoping it might have said the father was a ship's carpenter but it just stated that Thomas was a mariner so probably doesn't get me much further.

I also sent for the death certificate of the Thomas who died in 1852.  This was the same Thomas who fathered the Isabella born in Birkenhead but but the certifcate just describes him as a seaman.  Interestingly, he was found drowned in Edgerton Dock, Birkenhead so there could be an interesting story there if I can prove he was the father of my Isabella!  His wife would only have been in her early twenties so could well have subsequently partnered a Robert as Bert suggested.I

I haven't had any luck in proving the Sarah Mills on the 1871 census is the same person as Sarah Hill, who was a witness at Isabella's marrieage in 1872 so I am going to look for any evidence of Isabella Barton born 1851 in Birkenhead on records after the 1871 census - if I can then it proves she is not the Isabella I am looking for but if I can't find her on any record, I guess it still keeps the possibility alive.

If anyone comes across any records for an Isabella that might fit the bill, please let me know.  All help gratefully accespted!

Glen

 

The below I suspect is the wife of Thomas Barton, Esther Barton, nee Roscoe. It suggests she never remarried, perhaps the admission registers hold an address for her. Wirral Archives have the records, not sure if they are elsewhere like FMP,etc.

Bebington Cemetery.

Thanks, Bert - still no mention of a ship's carpenter, then!  I'll make some more checks and see if I can see anything that would link her to my Isabella.

Also, I want to correct something I posted before:  the 1852 death certificate does not refer to Esther's husband.  I had a look at the newpsper report with the death having been referred to the coroner and it mentions that the deceased Thomas was a flatman from Northwich.  A look at the 1851 census shows the dead man was probably born in Witton and had been waterman married to Jane nee Bebbington.

You're right, Mary - it certainly does get complicated!

Glen

 

I suspect her husband was still living, many others are described as Widow of ?,  Daughter of ?, Son of ? etc. etc.

Yes, I think it suggests Thomas was still alive too.

Given that I am trying to make a link between the Isabella Barton born in Birkenhead in 1851 and the Isabella Barton who married Thomas Maddox in 1872, I wondered if it might be worth finding out who reported the deaths of Thomas and Esther but given that Esther's would probably have been reported by the workhouse, I can't find Thomas's death and they didn't die in Liverpool anyway, perhaps it is too much of a long-shot to hope that one of the deaths may have been reported by their granddaughter Isabella Maddox!

However, I think Isabella's grandparents (Edward and Esther Roscoe) may have been living in Tenterden Street in Liverpool at the time of the 1871 census and both died there in 1871 and 1872 respectively so I am wondering if my long-shot might work with their death certificates (I guess Esther's would be my best bet).

Bert: I cannot make out the street Isabella Barton and Sarah Mills were working at in 1871 and I was wondering if you could decipher it and perhaps tell me if it was anywhere near Tenterden Street?

Many thanks,

Glen

Thanks, Bert - how on earth did I not deduce that!

I think I might go for it and send for Esther's death certificate and see if it gets me any closer to making the link.

I do think you might be on to something about the marriage certificate showing the wrong name for Isabella's father.  I mentioned Thomas Maddox and Isabella calling one of their daughters Esther, but another coincidence is that their eldest son was called Charles Edward - Charles was the name of Thomas's grandfather and Edward could be the name of Isabella's grandfather.

I'll post an update  when I get the certificate.

Regards,

Glen

If you separate the two Isabella's, the one from 1871 Canning St, born in Birkenhead and Isabella married to Thomas. The girl from Birkenhead doesn't appear to have had a future and Thomas's Isabella doesn't appear to have had a past.

The signature of Sarah, witness at the marriage is hard to decipher, I see it Mills or Hills but can't be certain. It would be a strange coincidence that Isabella was enumerated with a Sarah Mills, 1871 and then possibly appearing at Thomas marriage.

If you track the Isabella Barton's registered Liverpool and Birkenhead between 1845-1855 only one falls into the age bracket and that's the one born in Birkenhead.

After Thomas/Isabella marriage, Isabella declares herself born in Liverpool, worst case scenario the married Isabella wasn't registered or Baptised, born illegitimate and made up a father's name.

 

Opinions on signature below please.

 

I see where you are coming from, Bert.  Add to all that you have said that there doesn't seem to be any Robert Barton anywhere that fits the bill, it is certainly tempting to assume that the Isabella whom Thomas married was the same Isabella born in Birkenhead but there are still those 2 discrepencies: Thomas/Robert and Mills/Hill/Hills.

I have found a Sarah Mills born in Doncaster (place of birth on 1871 census) in 1846 and a Sarah Hill born there in 1844, which would coincide with the d.o.b. on the census.  But this isn't relevant if the woman was married  - the marital status isn't all that clear on the census.  Also, anyone got on views on whether a 27 year old cook would be a live-in servant if she was married?

Esther Roscoe's death certificate should come by the end of the week - oh for it to say her death was reported by Isabella Maddox, granddaughter!

G

 

Don't forget Isabella wasn't a Maddox until December 1872 and Esther died January 1872, hopefully there is other relevant information that will help. 

Aghhh! You're right - I was getting carried away and perhaps mixed up with Esther Roscoe's death and Esther Barton's death.  Isabella didn't become a Maddox until December 1872 and ER died in May!  I've not really got a plan after all - I've sent for the death certificate so I'll just see what's on it.  The only address on Isabella's marriage certificate is Bevington Hill - same address for her and Thomas although the 1871 census has Thomas living in Addison Street - so not sure the address of the informant will help.  Does Bevington Hill fit in with Canning Street at all?

I think I may be running out of options on this bit of research - pity I can't sort the Mills/Hill conundrum out.

G

Just out of interest (I do think I am clutching at straws now), how far would Bevington Hill be from Tenterden Street?

.

St Albans where Thomas and Isabella married was about 200 yards from Tenterden Street. 

Though the Roscoe's had passed by then.

Thanks for all your help on this one, Bert.  There are certainly a lot of coincidences - the proximity of Tenterden Street and St Albans being another - but I guess I just haven't got that final bit of proof to show that the Isabella who married Thomas in 1872 was indeed the same Isabella who was born in Birkenhead in 1851.

Unfortunately, Esther Roscoe's death certifcate got me no further as her death was reported by the woman who lived next door to her at the time of the 1871 census.  I don't know what other records I can look at and can't think of any more avenues to investigate apart from the Mills/Hill connection.  I think I will come back to this at another time as it may be a bit of a long haul to show that they either are or are not the same person.  Perhaps one for those long winter nights - as long as we have power to fire up the computer!

Thanks again, Bert - I would never have thought of following-up the Birkenhead link and I still think there may be something in it - I'll keep you posted if anything turns up!

Kind regards,

Glen

 

 

Married twice ?

By Munchkim |

I am hoping the expertise here may clear up a conundrum

I have been researching a Liverpool Merchant named John Lightbody(1756-1825). Later in life he moved to Mount House Prenton and was buried at Woodchurch. He was survived by his wife Jane (nee Pemberton) her maiden name is mentioned on the baptism of their daughter, Catherine Hannah in Jan 1791. I haven’t yet found found a marriage before that date. However I have found a later marriage at Christchurch, Hunter St in 1815. This appears to be the same person as the mother of his child. I have confirmed this by examining their wills. John leaves his estate to Jane.Jane then leaves her estate to her granddaughters Jane Alice and Catherine Hannah Gorton, who are the daughters of  Catherine Hannah Lightbody (born 1791) and Giles Gorton.

Is there a prospect that they may not have been married when their daughter was born although the baptism suggests otherwise.

Would there be any other circumstances in which a couple would marry for a 2nd time?

It appears no marriage took place prior to the baptism and without the pretence of marriage, in law the child would have been classed as illegitimate.

Some churches would have that recorded in their records. As far as I know, no proof of marriage is/was required to have a child baptised, it's done on trust, it's down to the honesty of the parents.

Also a second marriage is not permitted, though a blessing of the marriage is.

Bertie is quite right, however we have often found in our research that a marriage may not have taken place before a child was born and in fact this was often the case to prove that the woman was not barren, it seemed to be acceptable although not necessarily legal.